Skip to content

Results and records reviewer playbook ​

This page is for whoever clears the club's results and record claims. This is usually the Records Manager. It can also be a Results Reviewer, who handles only results. It takes about five minutes to read.

Who can do this?

Decide a result claim: Club Admin, Membership Manager, Records Manager or Results Reviewer. Decide a club record claim: Club Admin, Membership Manager or Records Manager. A Results Reviewer cannot open the list of record claims. A Viewer sees both lists but cannot act on either.

What you can do ​

  • Decide a member's result claim: accept it, correct it, reject it, or set aside an unclaimed import row.
  • Decide a club record claim: approve it, reject it, or amend the details around it.
  • Read the AI evidence check's reading of a claim's results page, where your club has switched it on. Say whether the reading was right.

Where you work ​

Both lists are under Performance in the volunteer console. A switch at the top shows Results or Records. The Records list also has its own address, /volunteer/records. Emails and push notifications link to this address. The address stays valid when the same list also appears inside Performance.

The Performance section with the Results/Records switch

the two lists under one tab, with the switch between them

Where claims come from ​

A result claim arrives in one of three ways. First, a member submits their own time with Submit results on their dashboard. Second, an import brings in the results of a whole race. The import stages each row that it cannot match to a member with confidence. Third, you reconcile one event's imported rows from that event's own page. That page shows the same list, narrowed to one race. A record claim always comes from a member who applies for a club record. The member sometimes points at a result claim that the record depends on.

RunClub HQ checks every time against the distance of the race. A member cannot type in a time that is faster than anyone has run the distance, or slower than walking pace. The member sees a message, for example "2 hours 5 minutes is too slow for this distance." An import cannot ask the member. It holds that row back for you, even when it recognised the runner. The row says Too fast for this distance or Too slow for this distance. Check the row against the published results. If someone mistyped it, choose Amend. If it is right, choose Accept to keep it as it is.

Review a result ​

Open a pending claim. The claim shows what the source said, word for word. Next to it, the claim shows who the club thinks ran the race. A member's own claim already names the member. For an import row that RunClub HQ could not match, the claim shows the published name. It also shows a suggested member. Tap the suggestion to confirm it. If the suggestion is wrong, choose Say who ran.

Below that, the claim shows these items:

  • The evidence link that the claim depends on, or the reason there is none.
  • The AI evidence check, if your club is in the beta (see below).
  • Anything else that claims the same performance. You can then never approve a duplicate by accident.

If the member already has a result for this event, RunClub HQ tells you before you decide.

A claim can add an unlisted race to the club calendar when you accept it. If it does, the page warns you above the button, not after. The warning also shows who added the event.

A result claim with the evidence panel open

a result claim, with the source row, the matched runner and the evidence link

A rejection tells the member, and you cannot undo it

Reject is offered only on a member's own claim. RunClub HQ emails the reason that you give to the member at once. You cannot bring a rejected claim back. If you reject a claim by mistake, ask the member to submit it again.

Choose Accept, Amend, Reject or Ignore. Amend changes the finish time, position or results link. It does not change the source's own words. Ignore sets aside an import row that nobody claimed. RunClub HQ never offers Ignore on a member's own claim. Ignore tells the member nothing.

When you amend, use the Admin comments box for a note to the rest of the committee. For example, write how you checked the time. The note shows on the claim for anyone who reviews it. The member never sees it.

A club record claim can depend on a result claim. If you reject the result claim, RunClub HQ also rejects each record claim that depends on it. A club record cannot depend on a performance that the club rejected. If you approve the record claim, RunClub HQ also accepts the result claim that it depends on.

Review a record claim ​

Open a pending claim from Records. The claim shows the claimed time, the event where the member set it, and the category. RunClub HQ works out the category from the runner's date of birth and gender on the day of the event. An example is Men V40 or Women Overall. Below that, the claim shows the same AI evidence check as a result claim. Then it shows the eligibility context: the current holder and time for that category, and whether this claim beats that time.

A record claim shown side by side with its evidence

a record claim, the category it was matched to, and the current holder

A rejection tells the applicant, and you cannot undo it

RunClub HQ emails the reason that you give to the applicant. You cannot bring a rejected claim back. If you reject a claim by mistake, ask the applicant to reapply.

Choose Approve. The records board updates at once. RunClub HQ emails the applicant and the record holder. These can be different people, for example a parent who applies for a junior. If the claim beats the previous time, RunClub HQ also emails the previous holder to say that their record is broken. You can also choose Reject. You can also choose Amend to change the time, the event details or the evidence link. You cannot change the category or the format. They are fixed when the member makes the claim. When you amend a record claim, you get the same Admin comments box as for a result claim. The box is kept apart from the applicant's own notes.

The AI check is beta ​

Beta — ask us to switch this on for your club. When it is on, the card shows the model's reading of the linked results page. The card shows a verdict, the exact line that the model read, and a short explanation. You can check the reading for yourself. The check never decides anything. It supports your judgement only. Choose Yes or No under the card to say whether the verdict was right. RunClub HQ records this feedback against the claim. The beta uses this feedback to improve.

The check sometimes cannot read a page. The page can be blocked or empty. The site can also be one that we leave alone after it refused us. The check never scores such a page as "not corroborated". It shows a fact about the site and tells you to open the link yourself. Nothing there counts against the claim.

If something goes wrong ​

Some results sites block automated readers. Some sites load their results after the page opens, so there is nothing to check. After a site refuses us, we leave it alone for a while before we try again. In all three cases, open the evidence link yourself and decide on what you see. None of the three is a verdict against the claim.

The claim is matched to the wrong person ​

Use Say who ran on a result claim to correct the match before you accept it. If a record claim names the wrong member, reject it and ask the member to reapply. The applicant chooses who a claim is about when they submit it. The record holder does not.

The claim is in the wrong category ​

RunClub HQ works out the category from the member's date of birth and gender at the time of the claim. Amend on a record claim cannot change it afterwards. If the category looks wrong, check the member's date of birth and gender on the member's own record. Correct them if they are wrong. See Members and households. Then reject the claim. Ask the member to reapply. The wizard then offers the right category.

What you cannot do ​

  • Create or edit competition formats or categories. These are in Settings, for a Club Admin.
  • Edit the event that a claim points at. That is in Events.
  • See the club's finances.

See also ​